Cilantro vs. Sage: Battle of KL’s fine dining sister restaurants

Having been away from home for some time, I’ve been wanting to check-out what the fine-dining scene in KL has become. For some years, the restaurant to beat in my eyes (until it shut down in 2009 for a year of refurbishment) was Cilantro. I’ve always felt that their trademark truffle butter and gorgeous pan-fried Unagi & Foie Gras were easily Michelin star worthy. In more recent years though, word on the street is that Cilantro’s sister restaurant, Sage, has also cemented itself as a favourite amongst haute cuisine loving locals. With both open for business again, I was posed with the dilemma of having to choose between the sisters. “Why not do both?” someone suggested. Why not indeed i thought… So, let the battle begin.

First up, the elder of the two sisters – Cilantro. On first looking, very little seems to have changed about the place despite the long renovations. We were greeted by the same familiar cream colours and grey suede interior… the same delicious truffle butter with freshly baked bread… and the same powerhouse of a wine list from which we chose a quite fabulous Adelaide Hills Pinot Noir. Sadly though, despite the same sky-high prices, few of the dinner dishes that night impressed as they did in the old days.

Unagi and Foie Gras with Mesclun

My once-favourite Unagi and Foie Gras starter was served far too hot temperature-wise. The crumbed batter tasted saturated in burning oil, almost as if it came straight out of a deep-fat-fryer. Once it finally cooled down though, I did at least manage to savour a bite or 2 of the fantastic flavours from the eel and luxuriously rich foie gras. A dish which truly defines head chef Takashi Kimura’s fusion French-Japanese style.

Char-grilled Wagyu Beef with Kinome

My Char-grilled Wagyu Beef main course was a bit of a let down. I expect big things from these sacred cows that live a life of luxury and being massaged all day. Though the inside of the steak was a nice medium-rare, I found the outer layer of the meat dry and shrivelled from over-searing. Add to that a rather watery gravy, plain-jane mash and minty pungent taste from the Kinome leaf garnish and what you get is a dish I would much rather forget. I’ve had much better Wagyu elsewhere.

My sister didn’t fare much better with her main either. Her monthly special of Scallops with black truffle was disappointing to say the least. The scallops though well-cooked, were under-seasoned… I suspect deliberately so as to allow the flavours of the black truffle shavings to shine. I don’t know if we overkilled too much of their delicious truffle butter at the start, but the truffle shavings themselves tasted completely flat, lacking any characteristic earthy flavour whatsoever. Not even a generous offering of extra truffle shavings from the waiting staff could save the dish.

Espresso Jelly, Blanc Manger and Kahlua ice-cream

Cilantro’s desserts have never really blown me off my feet, so expectations were not all that high going into the finale. Thankfully, my rhubarb souffle (which I forgot to photograph altogether) was actually very decent. The souffle was well-risen and had a nice airy, eggy sweetness to it offset by the sharp zing from the rhubarb filling. What was a bit of a disaster though was my sister’s Espresso Jelly and Blanc Manger dessert. I found the Blanc Manger and unsweetened coffee jelly completely bland. All you got after the flavours amalgamated was watered down coffee and almonds. Yee-uckk.

All in all, bitterly disappointing given how much I used to love Cilantro. At over RM 300 per person for dinner including wine, disappointment doesn’t come cheap either.

What of its younger sister then? Well for starters, Sage’s RM100 3-course Discovery set lunch menu, though limited in choice, offers far better value for the same Cilantro-esque French-Japanese haute cuisine. Jo was in town to visit and after two weeks of gorging ourselves with local Malaysian food, we were looking forward to a change of cuisine before flying back to London. Located on the rooftop of The Gardens @ MidValley, the setting is contemporary, spacious and clean-cut but a little sterile if you ask me.

Warm Fedelini Pasta with Roasted Foie Gras

My starter of warm Fedelini pasta with Roasted Foie Gras was an interesting adventure down the French-Japanense fusion tightrope. The pasta, served in a light Asian-style spring onion duck broth was topped off with a glorious slab of foie gras. I found the flavours a little confused depending on what I put into the mouth in what order. But serve me such a generous piece of foie gras on a plain white rice and I would still happily lap all of it up.

Smoked Norwegian Salmon with Beetroot confit and Wasabi

The salmon which both Jo and my mother opted for was even more impressive. A beautiful, thick slab of subtly home-smoked fish that was perfectly balanced by the sweetness of the beetroot and spicy kick from the wasabi vinaigrette. Like a never-ending feast of sashimi, only better. Dee-licious.

Glazed Atlantic sea-bass with sea-urchin butter

Both main courses were also completely on the money. My miso-glazed Atlantic sea-bass was cooked to clinical perfection – the skin extremely crisp and the large flakes of seabass melted in the mouth like a dream. It was wonderfully complemented by the smooth sea-urchin flavoured butter which was sweet yet tasted of the sea all at the same time.

Angus Rossini with Truffle mash and red wine sauce

I had purposely steered clear of the steak as I wanted to keep lunch light. But had I known how good the Angus Rossini was going to be, I would have ordered it in a flash. The Angus fillet steak was very tender, and like the seabass, seemed to melt away in the mouth like butter. Then came the explosion of flavours from the bold red wine sauce and the velvety truffle mash. Miles better than the Wagyu I had at Cilantro just a few days earlier.

Earl grey Bavarois with Milk Ice Cream and Chocolate Anglaise

Dessert was a shrewd, deconstructed take on Earl grey tea and milk. I particularly liked the tea-flavoured bavarois jelly as it had just the right intensity of earl-greyness without being overpowering. Very nice with the milky, soft-serve style vanilla ice-cream. It wasn’t the prettiest of dishes, but it brought proceedings to a happy end.

On the whole, Sage is serving up some pretty sophisticated and exquisite food. Sure, the plating and presentation isn’t mindblowing, but with the set lunch menu at a third of the price of a Cilantro dinner, its a no brainer as to which I will pay homage to when I’m ever back in KL again. Haute cuisine in Malaysia still has a some way to go to before it can compete with the Michelin-starred big boys of abroad. But at least where old favourites have faded out, new stars have emerged to take their place.


Cilantro Restaurant & Wine Bar

MiCasa All Suite Hotel,
368-B, Jalan Tun Razak,
50400 Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.

Sage Restaurant & Wine Bar

The Gardens Residences Level 6,
Mid Valley City,
Lingkaran Syed Putra,
59200 Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia